Now Kamal Nath Says Manmohan Singh May Have Made a Mistake

NEW DELHIAfter former Comptroller and Auditor General or CAG Vinod Rai attacked Manmohan Singh on the 2G issue, Congress leader Kamal Nath today said the former Prime Minister may have made a "mistake" in not acting despite his letter to him expressing concern over the spectrum allocation process.

"He may have made a mistake. I would go along with you. I brought it to his notice. He did not understand the import and he did not act," Mr Nath said to a private news channel.

"I was disappointed that the Prime Minister did not act.... In retrospect and hindsight, the gravity and magnitude was not known. It was not known to me and the PM. It is very unfair to say that he knew everything," the former Union Minister and Mr Singh's party colleague said.

His remarks came even as several Congress leaders defended Mr Singh on the 2G issue. The party too downplayed Mr Nath's remarks and rejected the contention that the same had vindicated Mr Rai's argument that Mr Singh could not shirk responsibility for decisions to allocate 2G telecom spectrum and coal blocks.

Asked if things would have been different had Manmohan Singh acted differently, Mr Nath said, "As recommended in my letter, if a group or a Cabinet Committee was set up, obviously the process would have changed. It required sharper and more focused attention".

"If it would not have been left to one minister alone, things would have been different," he told a private news channel.

Mr Nath said that the CAG came much later and he had written the letter earlier. "We must understand that the CAG report came much later. We did not know that."

Mr Nath dismissed the BJP's charge that 10 Janpath was involved and Sonia Gandhi told the Prime Minister to not pursue the matter.

"BJP is talking absolute rubbish. Sonia Gandhi, 10 Janpath did not know what was happening...Only the department knew what was happening not the entire government," he said.

Mr Nath wondered that the CAG "never stumbled upon my letter, which was on record".

Replying to a question, he said, "I do not believe that the Prime Minister knew all the facts. I do not think he knew large parts of the facts."

At the All India Congress Committee or AICC briefing, party spokesperson Abhishek Singhvi rejected the contention that Mr Nath had vindicated Mr Rai's charge.

"Nath has said nothing of the sort what Rai said. It's a complete distortion to compare the two...Many people write letters, raise their concerns...Rai is speaking of complicity. Then he should have filed an FIR, become a witness...It is nothing but an exercise in self-advancement, self promotion," he said.

In Disaster-Hit Kashmir, a Collective Story of Human Determination


SRINAGARThe line was nothing less than a kilometer long. And, as the sun dipped, it was nothing short of a deluge, a mass of humanity. 

The Jammu - Srinagar highway is still closed. Large landslides at Ramsu just ahead of Banihal tunnel - the divides Jammu from Kashmir valley - have blocked the crucial highway. The only way to get out of the valley is via the aerial route.

But that is hardly a hurdle. Like Hannibal's army of yore - this army too, that of migrant workers in the valley, have walked over an entire mountain range to reach Jammu. They have walked through the mountains to reach Ramban in Jammu. Some have walked for as many as six days without any food and water for most of those days. 

"We noticed them yesterday, nearly 8,000 people crossed over today.  About 10,000 crossed over yesterday," said Brigadier Bhubesh Commader of the 11 sector of Rome Force. 

The army, he said, is making every effort to open the highway but it will take time. "We have opened a few langars (community kitchen) and medical camps at either side of the land side. Once they cross over, we put them on buses which are ferrying them to the Udhampur railway station," he said.

The exodus is a story of human grit, endurance and of human survival instinct. 

"We had nothing to eat for three days because of the rains; as soon as the weather improved I started walking," said Sunil Kumar Paswan from Bihar. He said that he tried taking shelter in a school and then in a hospital, but could not. 

"The police threw us out of the hospital and asked us to get lost," he said.  

On his way, he sold his mobile because he had no money. 

"I was thrown out by my employers as the water level started rising. They didn't pay me," alleged Rafiq from Bihar.

We met several survivors who, like Sunil, had either been asked to leave or had not been paid. Most labourers like Sunil and Rafiq were contracted to work in the fields, brick kilns and in other such odd jobs in the valley.

We found a young woman at the make-shift transit camp at the Ramban bus station. She was feeding her year two-year-old child. It was the first meal for them in three days.  

The langar is a combined effort between the local administration, the India Army, and the local people of Ramban. 

"I will go back to my village in Malda (in West Bengal) and then let's see what's in store," she told me as a volunteer put more hot daal androti on her plate by a volunteer at the camp. 

Disasters and deaths often bring out the worst in people; sometimes, the best of all that makes us human.

Voting for By-Polls in 10 States Begins; Will Modi Wave Continue?




NEW DELHI Gujarat's Vadodara constituency vacated by Prime Minister Narendra Modi is among the 36 Lok Sabha and assembly seats across 10 states where by-elections are being held.

As polling began, the Prime Minister, in a tweet, urged voters "across the country today to vote in large numbers".   

                                        Here are the latest developments:



(1)  PM Modi won Vadodara by nearly six lakh votes, which was the highest victory margin in the national election that saw his BJP winning a decisive mandate to rule the country. Mr Modi chose to retain Varanasi in UP, the second constituency that he won.


(2)Ranjan Ben Bhatta is the BJP candidate in Vadodara against Narendra Rawat of the Congress.

(3) MAINPURI:  Tej Pratap Yadav, a Leeds University graduate, is the latest member of Mulayam Singh Yadav's family to enter Uttar Pradesh politics. He is the Samajwadi Party candidate in the by-elections to be held on Saturday for the Mainpuri Lok Sabha seat.
 
The seat was vacated by Mulayam Singh after the national elections; the Samajwadi Party chief contested and had won two seats in Uttar Pradesh, which his party rules. Tej Pratap is the grandson of Mulayam's older brother Ratan Singh Yadav.

The 26-year-old refutes the charge that he is a product of dynastic politics and says he has been living in Saifai, the family village, for the last few years and is contesting "on popular demand."

Tej Pratap appears to be confident that he will win the seat that his grand uncle has won five times. He is dismissive of the BJP - which had won 71 of UP's 80 Lok Sabha seats in this year's national elections - saying that the people are "tired of its divisive politics."

"In the last bypolls, be it Bihar or Karnataka, everywhere the BJP has lost. This means that the popular sentiment accompanying the Lok Sabha elections has now died down and I am confident that the people of Uttar Pradesh will give their verdict in favor of the Samajwadi Party this time," said Mr Yadav in Mainpuri.
 
With an MBA from Amity University, he went on to do an MSc in Management from the UK. He has been part of the party's organisation in Saifai and was Mulayam's election agent during the Lok Sabha polls.
 
Today is the last day of campaigning for the by-elections for 11 assembly and 1 Lok Sabha seats in Uttar Pradesh. A resurgent BJP takes on the ruling Samajwadi Party, headed in the state by Tej Pratap's uncle Akhilesh Yadav, who faces criticism for not being able to check growing incidents of communal tension.

(4)NEW DELHI A police case or FIR should be filed against the BJP's Yogi Adityanath for allegedly promoting religious enmity, the Election Commission said today. The BJP's star campaigner in Uttar Pradesh delivered a speech recently designed to incite communal tension, the Commission has found. It has also written to the controversial leader, warning him to be careful.

Adityanath, a senior priest and a 42-year-old law-maker from Uttar Pradesh, was also listed today along with other leaders from his party in another FIR for defying  the state government to hold a rally in Lucknow on Wednesday evening.

Adityanath said that he went ahead with the public meeting despite being refused permission by local officials "to fight against the UP government's dictatorship and undemocratic ways." The rally has been filmed and will be scrutinized by the Election Commission to determine what action should be taken next.  

On Saturday, Uttar Pradesh will hold by-elections for eleven assembly seats and one parliamentary constituency.  Adityanath has also questioned the authenticity of a video that appeared online a few weeks ago that shows him making hate remarks against Muslims
In the national election in May, the BJP won 71 of the 80 parliamentary seats in Uttar Pradesh.

Critics claim the outstanding result was accomplished by Amit Shah through a strategy pivoted on stirring communal tensions for electoral advantage. Mr Shah, a top aide of Prime Minister Narendra Modi and now the BJP president, has denied those charges.

Yesterday, he was charge-sheeted by the UP police for allegedly making a hate speech ahead of the national elections in Muzaffarnagar, which was seared by deadly Hindu-Muslim riots in September.

In his Independence Day speech, the Prime Minister called for an end to communal violence.

But ahead of the by-elections, local BJP leaders have been accused of trying to polarize voters by focusing on forced conversions and "love jihad" - what they describe as an Islamist strategy to convert Hindu women through seduction, marriage and money.


(5) By-polls are also being held to the Medak Lok Sabha seat vacated by Telangana Rashtra Samithi (TRS) Chief K Chandrasekhar Rao after he became the first Chief Minister of Telangana.

(6)Polling is also taking place in 13 assembly seats in Assam, Andhra Pradesh, Chhattisgarh, Rajasthan, Sikkim, Tripura and West Bengal.

(7)The votes will be counted on Tuesday.

(8)In by-polls last month in Bihar, Karnataka, Madhya Pradesh and Punjab, the BJP's score was less than impressive. In Bihar, the alliance of former rivals Lalu Prasad Yadav and Nitish Kumar, along with the Congress, scored an impressive six out of 10 assembly seats. The BJP won four, which rivals said reflected voters' disappointment in three months of the new government.

(9)The BJP also lost in Bellary in Karnataka, winning only one of three seats by a very modest margin.

(10)The next round of polling will be held on October 15, when two major Congress-ruled states, Maharashtra and Haryana, will vote for new assemblies. The verdict will be announced on October 19.